NSEC3 & CDS

Authenticated denial (NSEC vs NSEC3), RFC 9276 iteration compliance and automated key rollover (CDS/CDNSKEY) · all insights

Signed zones prove that a name does not exist with NSEC or NSEC3 records. RFC 9276 recommends NSEC3 with zero extra iterations and no salt; this page measures how many .dk zones follow that, which providers don't, and who publishes CDS/CDNSKEY for automated key rollovers. Data comes from our own scanners, which re-resolve every .dk domain in the zone roughly once a week.

Based on 1,214,681 domains probed so far (92.5% of the zone). A domain's probe is refreshed with every full scan, and otherwise roughly every 30–35 days, so while the first pass is still filling in the numbers can shift.

NSEC3 iterations#

Of 836,008 signed zones probed whose denial of existence we could see (a signed wildcard zone answers every name, so it shows none), 474,434 (56.7%) use NSEC3, 344,142 (41.2%) use a classic NSEC chain, which lets anyone list every name in the zone, and 17,432 (2.1%) use compact denial (RFC 9824, Cloudflare's "black lies"), which can't be walked. RFC 9276 asks NSEC3 zones for 0 extra iterations and no salt: iterations cost resolvers CPU for no security gain. 223,720 NSEC3 zones (47.2%) still use iterations and 224,132 use a salt; 1,629 use opt-out.

IterationsZonesShare
0250,714
52.8%
1208,644
44.0%
43
0.0%
59
0.0%
710,185
2.1%
812
0.0%
103,960
0.8%
1212
0.0%
132
0.0%
141
0.0%
2016
0.0%
2119
0.0%
50856
0.2%
991
0.0%

List the zones with iterations > 0 →

NSEC3 by DNS provider#

ProviderNSEC3 zonesIterations > 0Salted
one.com223,3530.1%0.1%
dandomain.dk106,800100.0%100.0%
curanet.dk52,735100.0%100.0%
scannet2.dk22,054100.0%100.0%
hyp.net11,4620%0.0%
wannafind.dk8,015100.0%100.0%
dnsserver.dk6,444100.0%100.0%
punktum.dk6,18246.7%46.7%
nordicway.dk5,76456.7%56.7%
e-studio.dk3,91697.7%97.7%
loopia.se3,3210%0.0%
sitnet.dk2,694100.0%100.0%
123hotel.dk1,768100.0%100.0%
aveo.dk1,540100.0%100.0%
netgiganten.dk1,12398.7%98.7%
simpleagencygroup.dk995100.0%100.0%
gnrx.dk955100.0%100.0%
wixdns.net918100.0%100.0%
nhl-data.dk7520%0.0%
hostonline.dk713100.0%100.0%
yayhosting.dk70899.6%99.6%
dnsadmin.dk70689.4%100.0%
desec.io6900%0.0%
azehosting.net65785.8%85.8%
web-solutions.dk4600%0.0%

CDS / CDNSKEY (automated DS updates)#

CDS and CDNSKEY records let a DNS operator hand key rollovers to the registry automatically (RFC 7344/8078). 312,859 of the 887,736 signed zones we asked (35.2%) publish them; 770 publish the delete signal, asking the registry to remove their DS and turn DNSSEC off.

Zones with NSEC3 iterations > 0#

100,000+ zones