NSEC3 & CDS

Authenticated denial (NSEC vs NSEC3), RFC 9276 iteration compliance and automated key rollover (CDS/CDNSKEY) · all insights

Signed zones prove that a name does not exist with NSEC or NSEC3 records. RFC 9276 recommends NSEC3 with zero extra iterations and no salt; this page measures how many .dk zones follow that, which providers don't, and who publishes CDS/CDNSKEY for automated key rollovers. Data comes from our own scanners, which re-resolve every .dk domain in the zone roughly once a week.

Based on 1,212,889 domains probed so far (92.5% of the zone). A domain's probe is refreshed with every full scan, and otherwise roughly every 30–35 days, so while the first pass is still filling in the numbers can shift.

NSEC3 iterations#

Of 833,152 signed zones probed whose denial of existence we could see (a signed wildcard zone answers every name, so it shows none), 472,419 (56.7%) use NSEC3, 343,359 (41.2%) use a classic NSEC chain, which lets anyone list every name in the zone, and 17,374 (2.1%) use compact denial (RFC 9824, Cloudflare's "black lies"), which can't be walked. RFC 9276 asks NSEC3 zones for 0 extra iterations and no salt: iterations cost resolvers CPU for no security gain. 223,523 NSEC3 zones (47.3%) still use iterations and 223,933 use a salt; 1,628 use opt-out.

IterationsZonesShare
0248,896
52.7%
1208,439
44.1%
43
0.0%
59
0.0%
710,202
2.2%
812
0.0%
103,951
0.8%
1212
0.0%
132
0.0%
141
0.0%
2016
0.0%
2119
0.0%
50856
0.2%
991
0.0%

List the zones with iterations > 0 →

NSEC3 by DNS provider#

ProviderNSEC3 zonesIterations > 0Salted
one.com222,0450.1%0.1%
dandomain.dk106,778100.0%100.0%
curanet.dk52,661100.0%100.0%
scannet2.dk22,064100.0%100.0%
hyp.net11,4650%0.0%
wannafind.dk8,018100.0%100.0%
dnsserver.dk6,444100.0%100.0%
punktum.dk5,91046.8%46.9%
nordicway.dk5,75156.9%56.9%
e-studio.dk3,91697.6%97.6%
loopia.se3,3160%0.0%
sitnet.dk2,687100.0%100.0%
123hotel.dk1,768100.0%100.0%
aveo.dk1,543100.0%100.0%
netgiganten.dk1,12598.7%98.7%
simpleagencygroup.dk991100.0%100.0%
gnrx.dk955100.0%100.0%
wixdns.net920100.0%100.0%
hostonline.dk713100.0%100.0%
dnsadmin.dk70889.4%100.0%
yayhosting.dk70899.6%99.6%
desec.io6900%0.0%
azehosting.net65885.9%85.9%
web-solutions.dk4600%0.0%
podi.dk439100.0%100.0%

CDS / CDNSKEY (automated DS updates)#

CDS and CDNSKEY records let a DNS operator hand key rollovers to the registry automatically (RFC 7344/8078). 312,033 of the 886,179 signed zones we asked (35.2%) publish them; 761 publish the delete signal, asking the registry to remove their DS and turn DNSSEC off.

Zones with NSEC3 iterations > 0#

100,000+ zones
DomainIterationsSalt
10klassecenteret.dk508 bytes
10klassecentret.dk508 bytes
10mb.dk11 bytes
10minbutik.dk78 bytes
10minomdagen.dk11 bytes
10minutteromdagen.dk11 bytes
10nf.dk11 bytes
10odense.dk508 bytes
10pro.dk11 bytes
10r.dk11 bytes
10shirt.dk78 bytes
10spir.dk107 bytes
10steps.dk11 bytes
10tal.dk11 bytes
10talbogføring.dk11 bytes
10vejle.dk508 bytes
10x.dk18 bytes
10øren.dk11 bytes
110310renovering.dk11 bytes
1108.dk11 bytes
111012.dk11 bytes
1113.dk11 bytes
1115.dk78 bytes
112-vejen.dk11 bytes
112-vvs.dk11 bytes
112.dk78 bytes
1129.dk11 bytes
112a.dk11 bytes
112akademiet.dk11 bytes
112akuthjaelper.dk11 bytes
112app.dk11 bytes
112brandslukker.dk11 bytes
112cfo.dk11 bytes
112kaeledyr.dk11 bytes
112kæledyr.dk11 bytes
112news.dk11 bytes
112politi.dk11 bytes
112vejen.dk11 bytes
112vvs.dk11 bytes
1133.dk11 bytes
113skab.dk11 bytes
1147.dk11 bytes
1148.dk11 bytes
1152.dk78 bytes
117-kjoler.dk11 bytes
117kjoler.dk11 bytes
11a.dk78 bytes
11thhour.dk11 bytes
11thhourconsulting.dk11 bytes
12-01-2010.dk11 bytes