SOA Serials & Timers

Serial formats (date, Unix time, counter) and SOA timers against RFC 1912 · all insights

Every zone's SOA record carries a serial number and timers. The serial format reveals how the zone is managed, and the timers should follow RFC 1912 and RFC 2308. This page shows both across .dk and per DNS provider. Data comes from our own scanners, which re-resolve every .dk domain in the zone roughly once a week.

Serial number formats#

FormatZonesShare
Date (YYYYMMDDnn)1,018,632
85.6%
Other109,863
9.2%
Unix timestamp32,958
2.8%
Small counter29,182
2.5%

The serial format fingerprints how a zone is managed: date-based serials are the classic convention, Unix timestamps usually mean automation, small counters are typical of some DNS software. 91 date-style serials are dated in the future.

SOA timers vs recommendations#

TimerRecommended rangeZones within
Refresh20 min – 12 h97.6%
Retry2 min – refresh99.5%
Expire2 – 4 weeks78.1%
Negative TTL (minimum)5 min – 1 day99.1%
All four77.1%

Refresh, retry and expire ranges follow RFC 1912 §2.2. For the negative-caching TTL (the SOA minimum field, RFC 2308) we accept 5 minutes to 1 day; RFC 2308 suggests 1–3 hours and calls anything over a day problematic.

By DNS provider#

ProviderZonesDate serialUnixCounterTimers OKAvg negative TTL
simply.com286,950100%0%0%100%3,600 s
one.com273,100100%0%0%100%674 s
dandomain.dk106,941100%0%0%100%300 s
cloudflare.com98,2620%0%0%0%1,804 s
curanet.dk53,107100%0%0%100%300 s
scannet2.dk22,18699%0%0%100%300 s
webhosting.dk20,12084%0%0%0%664 s
nordicway.dk18,655100%0%0%100%86,396 s
domaincontrol.com16,915100%0%0%0%1,602 s
gigahost.dk16,158100%0%0%0%3,600 s
eurodns.com13,55599%1%0%85%85,365 s
hyp.net11,6310%100%0%100%3,600 s
wannafind.dk8,020100%0%0%100%300 s
azure-dns.com8,01812%1%87%79%6,356 s
azehosting.net7,732100%0%0%100%86,367 s
dns.services7,624100%0%0%98%10,005 s
cscdns.net6,93999%0%0%20%43,093 s
wixdns.net6,564100%0%0%99%3,601 s
dnsserver.dk6,491100%0%0%100%300 s
netsite.dk6,401100%0%0%94%3,652 s
dns-123.net5,948100%0%0%0%300 s
e-studio.dk5,436100%0%0%97%86,353 s
dns-parking.com5,215100%0%0%0%678 s
portsdns.se4,922100%0%0%30%23,702 s
bricksite.net4,019100%0%0%0%3,621 s